Carvajal (with a Shadow) > Scream Trippier > Semedo

Semedo is all pace, nothing else. Positioning is horrible, reactions slow, very weak, passing is shocking. People use him because of the pace and the links, that's it. Scream Trippier is a little better than Semedo. Carvajal needs a shadow for the pace boost, and with that, you have one of the best and most balanced non-icon RBs in the game. I tried all 3 and Carvajal is by far miles and miles better than Semedo, it's not even close. If you play with both you'll notice the difference.